Score: 10

"Wow, that was beautiful"

submission: RUPHOLD

date: December 31, 2008

I don't understand why the score was so low. Well, I guess if it isn't funny then it doesn't get the high scores like other animations out there. As you can see, most of the top animations are all comedies and I can think of atleast 5 other animations that are way better than the ones up there. But I shouldn't complain. I think this deserves an award of some sort. The animation was really well done. The slow motion parts were especially the most impressive. I have to commend you on the effort you put on this. Hopefully you'll get your day when you kick ass score wise and get the popularity you deserve. For this, I think you just choose the wrong day. Never submit on the day you know there is gonna be a huge group of Christmas flashes. Today would have been a good day to submit. Or even yesterday. Anyways, good luck on your future efforts. Favorited

Score: 8

"This is very relaxing"

submission: Snowbot

date: December 31, 2008

I like this animation. It's very mellow and chill. I can see the beginning part as a screensave or something. Good work man!.

Score: 9

"Brilliant... just brilliant"

submission: Rat Episode 2

date: December 31, 2008

I thought the artwork was gorgeous man. The opening sequence was the best part of the cartoon. It definitely introduced you to the atmosphere of the world. The entire episode had my eyes glued to the screen. The only problem I had with this was the audio. It was very low and scratchy and I could barely hear the voices. I tried to read the subtitles, but the font was just unreadable. You should have just used like a regular font like arial or times new roman. Anyways, the artwork and animation was awesome. I love the way the rat (I guess that's what you would call them) runs. But, it wish the audio was done better. Overall, it was a great effort. I don't think I got everything out of the story like I should have and that just may be my fault, but the artwork was pro. Favorited and Good luck on your future efforts man. Love your work

Score: 10

"Loved the Dolls"

submission: Wish Liszt

date: December 26, 2008

The animation was really good man, especially since you only did it in like 3 weeks. I'm glad you mustered up enough energy to get this out. My favorite part of the animation is where the dolls are braiding her hair together. I also like where the bear jumps into the girl's hands. Everything moved smoothly. The only part that probably needed work was just the pirate part. There was a particular shot where it kind of flashed and looked like the ship was already close to the screen, then it goes back to tweening from the back to the front. I don't know, there was just a problem with that shot right when it cuts to the pirate part. Other than that I thought everything else was great. Love the story and how you made the toys come to life. Good Job and Good Luck

Score: 9

"Oh My....."

submission: OH, Here it Goes...

date: December 24, 2008

Everything went really well with the music. The animation was very smooth, especially in the middle of the animation. There were some sketchy parts, but its pretty amazing how you guys finished this in only a week or so. Anyways, I loved the music in this. Also, the story was really funny. There were alot of quick moments where I laughed where either the main character knocked people down or just the expressions. If I had to pick a part, I would have to say my favorite was the scene where he gave his friend his wallet.
All in all, it was a great Christmas submission. Good luck on future projects!

Score: 8

"The Rockin' Elf"

submission: Merry Ricksmas 2

date: December 17, 2008

Despite the low quality sound, I really enjoyed this flash. the frame by frame animation was incredibly well done, especially the part where Santa and the elf shake hands. I generally like cartoons with the bad guy trying to foil someones plans and ends up getting hurt in the process. Reminds me of the day when I used to watch Tom and Jerry or Roadrunner. Anyways, the story ended like I thought it would because I was waiting for the band to show up :). I have to take some points off for the sound fx and there were a few gripes I had with some of the lines because I couldn't really hear everything. However, this is definitely worth checking out and good luck with the contest

Score: 10

"That crazy Spider!"

submission: Office Spider: Episode 6

date: December 11, 2008

That was hilarious man. The ending with the intern made me laugh. If I had to predict the next episode it would probably be office spider being arrested for murder, but he usually gets away with that stuff so he's pretty much like O.J Simpson, except there are no bloody gloves. Good choice using the music from Always Sunny in Philadelphia. It went well with what was going on. Its hard to write this review and not spoil anything for anyone who hasn't watched it yet. I'll just say I enjoyed it alot and can't wait for another episode. Peace

Score: 9

"I loved this short"

submission: Fisherman?

date: December 11, 2008

That was hilarious. I would have never thought of fishing like that. Also, that guy deserved what he got at the end for being a douchebag. Anyways, The animation in this was very well done. Everything moved fluidly. The backgrounds look great in this as well. It looks like you put alot of time in drawing everything out. I hope you got an A for this because it was awesome. Definitely gonna favorite this short
-Kartunehustla

Score: 9

"Gotta Love Barry White"

submission: Love Song

date: December 9, 2008

You get extra points for using a Barry White song man. When I saw the shot of Santa shaking his butt to the music, that pretty much made me say "I'm gonna give this a five. The animation was very clean (at some points it was missing a few in-betweens, but it was still good nonetheless). I kind of wish it didn't end without finishing the song, but I thought you did a good job at giving it an end even when the song was barely over. Now I have to add this to my favorites to show my mom because she loves her some Barry White. Keep it up man... I loved every minute of this
-Kartunehustla

Score: 10

"Probably one, if not the best collab of 2008"

submission: ACML III: Bliss

date: December 8, 2008

It's a shame that the score is so low for this collab. It should definitely be higher, but I'm not gonna lie, when I pressed played, I was immediately bored by the long introduction you guys had before I even got to see the music video. Most of the people on newgrounds, including me, have very short attention spans. When i press play, I want to jump right into the animation. It took me about three tries before I took the time to watch the entire thing.... but it was worth it
For a collaboration, there wasn't a single bad part. Usually the thing that messes up a collab is that one person who has a horrible part that breaks the whole flow of the collab. Anyways, all of you guys did an excellent job with this. Don't worry if your score is lower than you hoped. Trust me when I say that you will get a front page and if this is not a daily first, there will definitely be people who will defend this. I will go out and say right now that this is the best collab this year.
This is definitely in my favorites. I hope you guys get the score you deserve because if i were one of you guys I'd be kind of pissed as well with the score it has now. When other people get like 4.40's for like average work at best. Well, I won't take anymore space. Good luck to you all on your future projects. Ten all the way
-KartuneHustla